agent picture

John Caltabiano

Financial Professional
Insurance Agent - Bankers Conseco Life Insurance Company
Direct Phone:
(718) 765-6233(718) 765-6233
Leave a Referral
agent picture

John CaltabianoInsurance Agent, Brooklyn, NY

request apt form icon
quote form icon
Meet John Caltabiano
Personal Business Philosophy
I'm dedicated to helping my clients protect their financial security as they prepare for retirement. I hold myself to the highest level of personal and professional integrity and promise only to recommend insurance product solutions that are in my client's best interests.
licensed in
NY
professional background
Joined Bankers Life in 2020Began work in the Insurance Industry in 2020Education: 2 Years of College, Special Courses in Finance Administration and Off Shore Insurance Programs
personal background
Family: Wife, 3 Step sons and one sonCommunity Involvement: Former President of Staten Island South Shore Rotary Club, Former Director of Staten Island Zoo and Former President and current Board of Boy Scouts Of America
additional languages
Italian

John Caltabiano, Bankers Life Agent in Brooklyn, NY

Closed - Opens at 9:00 AM Thursday
Contact Me
Office Phone:
(718) 765-6224(718) 765-6224
Direct Phone:
(718) 765-6233(718) 765-6233
Cell Phone:
(917) 602-6670(917) 602-6670
john.caltabiano@bankerslife.com
Branch Info
2913 Avenue W
Brooklyn, NY 11229
US
Hours
Day of the WeekHours
WednesdayClosed
Thursday9:00 AM - 5:00 PM
FridayClosed
SaturdayClosed
SundayClosed
Monday9:00 AM - 6:00 PM
TuesdayClosed

Products & Services Offered in Brooklyn, NY

  • Life Insurance

    Find out how life insurance can help protect the financial security of you and your family.
    Explore
  • Medicare Supplement Insurance

    Learn how Medicare supplement insurance can help cover out-of-pocket costs that Medicare may not cover.
    Explore
  • Long-term Care Insurance

    Find out how long-term care insurance can help provide financial security in the event of an unexpected long-term illness.
    Explore
  • Annuities

    Learn how an annuity can help protect and grow your retirement savings.
    Explore

Financial Calculators & Tools

Our calculators are here to help support your retirement and insurance planning needs so you can make confident and informed decisions.
Retirement Calculators
Insurance Calculators
  • How Long Will My Retirement Savings Last?

    Determine how long your retirement savings may last considering your monthly spending, sources of income, inflation and more.
  • Estimate Social Security Benefits

    Estimate your future Social Security benefits based on your income history and expected retirement age.
  • Traditional 401(k) or Roth 401(k)?

    How do traditional 401(k) and Roth 401(k) contributions differ, and which option best suits your financial needs?
  • Retirement Income Estimator

    Input your current savings and income sources to estimate your future retirement income and assess if you’re on track to meet your goals.
For information and educational purposes only. Does not constitute investment advice or a recommendation.

Forget Me Not Days

At Bankers Life, our insurance agents and associates witness firsthand the impact that Alzheimer’s and dementia have on our customers, their families and their caregivers. That’s why we established Bankers Life Forget Me Not Days®, our nationwide fundraising campaign to benefit the Alzheimer’s Association®. This June marks the 23rd anniversary of the campaign. Since 2003, we’ve helped raise more than $7.8 million for the Alzheimer’s Association through the Forget Me Not Days campaign and corporate donations.

Explore Medicare Advantage

You have many choices when it comes to Medicare – Let us help you compare Medicare Advantage plans to find the right coverage for you. Medicare Advantage (Part C) is an all-in-one alternative to Original Medicare Parts A and B.


Let's Talk About Your Plans for Long-Term Care!

As people live longer and health care expenses continue to rise, the need for long-term care becomes more of a "when" than an "if" situation. That's why it's so important to be prepared and have discussions with your loved ones. Ready to start planning your next steps?

Reviews

Reviews for John Caltabiano

5.0
Rating 5.0full star ratingfull star ratingfull star ratingfull star ratingfull star rating
(4 Reviews)
  • 5.0 out of 5.0
    Rating 5.0full star ratingfull star ratingfull star ratingfull star ratingfull star rating
    A very likable guy John is. Was a pleasure doing business with him.
Displaying reviews 1 - 1 out of the 4 most recent

Customer Reviews for Brooklyn, NY

4.9
Rating 4.8full star ratingfull star ratingfull star ratingfull star ratingfull star rating
(76 Reviews)
  • Marie E
    June 17, 2025
    5.0 out of 5.0
    Rating 5.0full star ratingfull star ratingfull star ratingfull star ratingfull star rating
    Great customer service
    Great customer service
    Read More
    Read Less
  • Karen M
    June 12, 2025
    5.0 out of 5.0
    Rating 5.0full star ratingfull star ratingfull star ratingfull star ratingfull star rating
    Working with Sandr has brought me a level of financial clarity and confidence I never thought possible. She took the time to understand not just my goals, but my values — and built a plan that reflects both. She is incredibly knowledgeable, especially when it comes to retirement planning and long-term care, and she explains complex topics in a way that’s easy to understand. I never feel rushed or pressured, just supported. I finally feel like I have someone in my corner who genuinely cares.
    Working with Sandr has brought me a level of financial clarity and confidence I never thought possible. She took the time to understand not just my goals, but my values — and built a plan that reflects both. She is incredibly knowledgeable, especially when it comes to retirement planning and long-term care, and she explains complex topics in a way that’s easy to understand. I never feel rushed or pressured, just supported. I finally feel like I have someone in my corner who genuinely cares.
    Read More
    Read Less
  • Cedric G
    May 2, 2025
    5.0 out of 5.0
    Rating 5.0full star ratingfull star ratingfull star ratingfull star ratingfull star rating
    Great courtesy public relations
    Great courtesy public relations
    Read More
    Read Less
  • Reuben W
    March 26, 2025
    5.0 out of 5.0
    Rating 5.0full star ratingfull star ratingfull star ratingfull star ratingfull star rating
    Mr Zhang presented himself with respect and knowledge of banking.I welcome Mr.Zhang back for future conversations which I hope to be not to far in future.Thank you
    Mr Zhang presented himself with respect and knowledge of banking.I welcome Mr.Zhang back for future conversations which I hope to be not to far in future.Thank you
    Read More
    Read Less
  • Irene I
    March 18, 2025
    5.0 out of 5.0
    Rating 5.0full star ratingfull star ratingfull star ratingfull star ratingfull star rating
    A very likable guy John is. Was a pleasure doing business with him.
    A very likable guy John is. Was a pleasure doing business with him.
    Read More
    Read Less
  • Marie E
    March 18, 2025
    5.0 out of 5.0
    Rating 5.0full star ratingfull star ratingfull star ratingfull star ratingfull star rating
    Friendly, knowledgeable and always ready to tackle my questions. I highly recommend her to anyone.
    I was highly satisfied.
    Friendly, knowledgeable and always ready to tackle my questions. I highly recommend her to anyone.
    I was highly satisfied.
    Read More
    Read Less
  • Mary S
    March 5, 2025
    5.0 out of 5.0
    Rating 5.0full star ratingfull star ratingfull star ratingfull star ratingfull star rating
    Thanks you very much for helping me with your services I really appreciate the offer and hope to asked for more information.
    Thanks you very much for helping me with your services I really appreciate the offer and hope to asked for more information.
    Read More
    Read Less
  • Gladys S
    February 15, 2025
    5.0 out of 5.0
    Rating 5.0full star ratingfull star ratingfull star ratingfull star ratingfull star rating
    Great
    Great
    Read More
    Read Less
  • William W
    February 13, 2025
    5.0 out of 5.0
    Rating 5.0full star ratingfull star ratingfull star ratingfull star ratingfull star rating
    A wonderful honest, direct transparent person who makes you feel completely at ease and believing his position of helping you.
    A wonderful honest, direct transparent person who makes you feel completely at ease and believing his position of helping you.
    Read More
    Read Less
  • Martha M
    February 5, 2025
    4.0 out of 5.0
    Rating 4.0full star ratingfull star ratingfull star ratingfull star rating
    Great Customer service
    Great Customer service
    Read More
    Read Less
  • Boris B
    February 5, 2025
    5.0 out of 5.0
    Rating 5.0full star ratingfull star ratingfull star ratingfull star ratingfull star rating
    Wonderful customer service
    Wonderful customer service
    Read More
    Read Less
  • Denise B
    January 28, 2025
    5.0 out of 5.0
    Rating 5.0full star ratingfull star ratingfull star ratingfull star ratingfull star rating
    Good customer service
    Good customer service
    Read More
    Read Less
  • Stephanie R
    January 18, 2025
    1.0 out of 5.0
    Rating 1.0full star rating
    Need to cancel our policy and he won’t give us the documents. We called the number to bankers life and can’t reach a representative. My father’s so very confused and now he’s stuck paying for something he does not want. Wishing we have luck on going to his office he told us it’s in Indiana.
    Need to cancel our policy and he won’t give us the documents. We called the number to bankers life and can’t reach a representative. My father’s so very confused and now he’s stuck paying for something he does not want. Wishing we have luck on going to his office he told us it’s in Indiana.
    Read More
    Read Less
    Response from Bankers Life
    January 21, 2025
    Hello Stephanie, thank you for leaving a rating and letting us know of your concern. A branch team member will be reaching out soon to assist with your request and address any outstanding issues. If you would like to reach out to the branch directly, their number is (718) 765-6224. If you have any issues, please email us at BLReviews@bankerslife.com.

  • Kate L
    December 31, 2024
    5.0 out of 5.0
    Rating 5.0full star ratingfull star ratingfull star ratingfull star ratingfull star rating
    I highly recommend reaching out to Peter for your Medicare needs. He came right to us, which we haven't experienced before. The meeting was very informative but in a relevant way. He brought a lot of things to our attention that I was unaware of- which ended up saving us a lot of money. He also assisted us with the financial information and resources we desperately needed to make sure we were on the right track with our retirement around the corner. All around he's such a nice guy. Thanks Peter!
    I highly recommend reaching out to Peter for your Medicare needs. He came right to us, which we haven't experienced before. The meeting was very informative but in a relevant way. He brought a lot of things to our attention that I was unaware of- which ended up saving us a lot of money. He also assisted us with the financial information and resources we desperately needed to make sure we were on the right track with our retirement around the corner. All around he's such a nice guy. Thanks Peter!
    Read More
    Read Less
  • Jessica H
    December 31, 2024
    5.0 out of 5.0
    Rating 5.0full star ratingfull star ratingfull star ratingfull star ratingfull star rating
    He was so kind and patient. And extremely helpful and knowledgeable. And an AMAZING personality. They were outstanding
    He was so kind and patient. And extremely helpful and knowledgeable. And an AMAZING personality. They were outstanding
    Read More
    Read Less
  • Edward M
    December 26, 2024
    5.0 out of 5.0
    Rating 5.0full star ratingfull star ratingfull star ratingfull star ratingfull star rating
    Excellent all across the board!!!!
    Excellent all across the board!!!!
    Read More
    Read Less
  • Lydia R
    December 18, 2024
    5.0 out of 5.0
    Rating 5.0full star ratingfull star ratingfull star ratingfull star ratingfull star rating
    It was a great visit and I gained much from it and I am grateful!
    It was a great visit and I gained much from it and I am grateful!
    Read More
    Read Less
  • Orlando R
    December 10, 2024
    5.0 out of 5.0
    Rating 5.0full star ratingfull star ratingfull star ratingfull star ratingfull star rating
    Ex.. Customer service!! Thanks Mr. Zhang.
    Ex.. Customer service!! Thanks Mr. Zhang.
    Read More
    Read Less
  • Alice J
    December 4, 2024
    5.0 out of 5.0
    Rating 5.0full star ratingfull star ratingfull star ratingfull star ratingfull star rating
    Great knowledge and great responses to all my inquiries
    Great knowledge and great responses to all my inquiries
    Read More
    Read Less
  • Wanda F
    November 5, 2024
    5.0 out of 5.0
    Rating 5.0full star ratingfull star ratingfull star ratingfull star ratingfull star rating
    A very nice person, very professional and understanding.
    A very nice person, very professional and understanding.
    Read More
    Read Less
Displaying reviews 1 - 4 out of the 20 most recent

FAQs

Our Brands and Partners

Our agents provide an expansive suite of insurance options, including core products offered by Bankers Life and Casualty Company, Colonial Penn Life Insurance Company and Washington National Insurance Company.

  • Bankers Life Logo
  • Colonial Penn Logo
Insights From John
Featured Videos
Find out how Bankers Life long-term care insurance can offer you or a loved one the flexibility and independence you deserve.
Find out how Bankers Life long-term care insurance can offer you or a loved one the flexibility and independence you deserve.
Featured Videos
Universal life insurance can play a vital role in your retirement strategy. It provides long-term, permanent life insurance coverage plus more!
Universal life insurance can play a vital role in your retirement strategy. It provides long-term, permanent life insurance coverage plus more!
Featured Videos
Find out how life insurance can be an important aspect of retirement planning. Learn about the different types of life insurance and why life insu...
Find out how life insurance can be an important aspect of retirement planning. Learn about the different types of life insurance and why life insurance is important for everyone, no matter their age.
Find out how life insurance can be an important aspect of retirement planning. Learn about the different types of life insurance and why life insurance is important for everyone, no matter their age.
A senior couple riding bikes.
What Role Can Alternative Investments Play in a Retirement Portfolio?
If you’re nearing retirement or already retired, feeling uneasy about potential market volatility is understandable. After years of saving and planning, it’s natural to want more stability in your portfolio. One option some retirees explore is adding alternative investments—assets beyond tradition...
Seniors discussing Medicare enrollment options with advisor.
When to Sign Up for Medicare If You’re Still Working at 65
"Turning 65 is a significant milestone, not just for making another trip around the sun but also for unlocking Medicare eligibility. As the federal health program for more than 68.5 million Americans, Medicare is a vital component of retirement planning.",You must pay a premium: Compare the costs an...
7 Smart Tips for Successfully Traveling Solo in 2025
Traveling solo is no longer a niche trend—it’s a growing movement. Whether you’re single, seeking solitude, or simply craving the freedom to explore on your own terms, solo travel offers flexibility and opportunities for personal growth. But if you’re new to it, it can feel intimidating. These seven...
Aging man looks thoughtful as he ponders his financial circumstances.
Finding Balance: How Financial Therapy Can Transform Your Money Mindset
Managing money can be a significant source of stress in life. For some, a simple tweak in their budget can bring clarity and stability. For others, financial challenges may stem from more complex issues, such as changes in financial circumstances, unhealthy spending habits, or emotional barriers. Th...
A senior couple pointing to a mountain.
Exploring Retirement Income Strategies in Any Economic Climate
Planning your income in retirement isn’t always straightforward, especially when the market feels unpredictable. But no matter the economic environment, having a thoughtful approach can help you feel more prepared.
A woman hugs her friend who has Alzheimer's disease.
Caring Through Connection: Helping a Friend with Alzheimer’s
Alzheimer’s disease affects nearly 7 million people in the U.S., and by 2050, it’s expected that number will rise to 13 million. If your friend is among them, it can be incredibly challenging to maintain your bond as the disease progresses. Watching someone you care about struggle with memory loss a...
Act Now For Your Free No-Obligation Quote